American Idol
Well… It’s Stevie Wonder week. Why? Why take a guy who you’ve complained about people singing and base the entire week around his songs? What’s next week… Mariah Carey? I hate artist theme weeks- I much prefer decades or style… Anyway… let’s get on with the performances….
Ace Young – Do I Do
Boring. Everything about this guy bores me… why do ya’ll keep voting for him?
Kellie Pickler – Blame It On The Sun
Boring. Not even any new food to tell us about this week….
Elliott Yamin – Knocks Me Off My Feet
Boring. My wife likes Elliott. I can’t stand him.
See what theme weeks do? I see a pattern starting….
Mandisa – Don’t You Worry ‘Bout a Thing
Mandisa was decent, but forgetable. The best part of her deal was when Ryan took her shoes off….
Bucky Covington – Superstition
Finally… somebody who I might listen to after this is over. Bucky is one of the few this year that I would listen to after this is over (along with Taylor and Chris)… I keep seeing him towards the bottom of polls, and I don’t get it…
Melissa McGhee – Lately
OMG… She forgot the words! First, in front of Stevie… then… on the show. How funny! Notice during the recap she suddenly sang it right? I always hated that they show practice sessions sometimes during the recap…
Lisa Tucker – Signed, Sealed, Delivered I’m Yours
Lisa did ok, but she was forgetable.
Kevin Covais – Part-Time Lover
Comic relief. First, I laughed all the way through his performance… then… I laughed through is attitude with Simon. This kid has a great future in stand up.
Not sure why he’s on AI though… But I hope he stays just for my entertainment.
Katharine McPhee – Until You Come Back to Me
Finally! The show started. What was all that other crap before this? I’vegot McPheever!
Talyor Hicks – Living for the City
Taylor is great! He knows how to work the crowd… his tourets style dancing works for him… he sings great… good job old man!
Paris Bennett – All I Do
I liked Paris during the auditions, but I am so done with it. I kept thinking her head was gonna fall off with her little bobblehead routine last night….
Chris Daughtry – Higher Ground
And of course… Chris steals the show again. This guy knows what the goal is… to actually have a career after all this. He’s well on hiis way, and he’s gonna do great.
Bottom three:
Kevin
Melissa
Ace
Going home:
Melissa
12 Comments »
Leave a reply to Angie Cancel reply
About
I'm just a guy trying to live my life the best I can. I am married to the woman of my dreams. I have a 8 year old daughter that I love dearly. I'm trying my best to keep my relationship with God as good as I can. I work too much, struggle with finances, have a family, house, pets, and misc. other stuff to keep up with along with trying to have my hobbies of woodworking and N-scale trains. Basically… I am living the American Dream and I couldn't be happier!
Recent Comments
Mannheimer Planetari… on Our old bathroom Bo Govoni on Top 5 American Idol… Krymaiustai on Wordless Wednesday John64 on The million dollar homepage… Mr.Carrot68 on The million dollar homepage… Links and things
Guppyman 
You want Kevin to stay?!? Bite your tongue!! I understand the comic relief..but come ON!! He and Melissa must go fast..then Ace and Bucky!!
But, you already know how I feel. 🙂
I agree with you this week, although Taylor is my favorite! Chris has a career no matter what happens on this show, so all my votes are going to Taylor and Katharine!
I think Melissa is done this week too, although, I much prefer Chicken Little to go next, but I think all the little chicks will keep voting for him.
my love affair with ace ended on his 2nd performance when he sang that daniel bedingfield song. so sad…
i agree with you about paris. she can sing but she irritates the heck out of me.
I agree with you that it’s counter productive to have these artist featured shows. The genre ones are much more interesting to me.
After all, how CAN anyone be expected to sing a Stevie Wonder song, that HE helped them rehearse, without it sounding like a Stevie Wonder ripoff?!
~~BA82
I can see doing SW week later on in the show, when you’re suppose to have the best singers left, but not this first week!
I hope your right babe..but I still think Kevin’s going but we’ll see tonight!
ok, ran across your site in an internet search for idol reviews and you came up, plus i went through ficken chingers comments and there you were…
i think your wrong and here is why. its good to do artist renditions early so that they get the scrubs out of the way before they get back into their comfort zones of genres, lifestyles, or decades. this is a good way of getting the fakers out of the way from the ones who are serious…plus, a good “singer” can sing anything, a good “performer” can fake it. i posted on fickin chingers site, and mine and i still say that either bucky or mellisa is leaving. my bet is on bucky. based on your review i can tell you like him but that performance was worst than melissa’s even though she forgot the lyrics…
twice…
on a live show…
and almost burst into tears…
but she has a good voice, bucky doesnt, and the wig didnt help either…
we will see tonight though.
thanks for the post, i enjoyed it, and good to see that there are other nerd besides me and fickin chingers posting live reviews…even better that your a dude too…see you later.
Wig??? ummm that was HIS hair lol I can see the above commenter has not seen all the shows. I think it will be either Kellie or Chicken Little. I think America has had enough of his ‘tude. The cute is annoying now. We shall see tonight though!
Wow Guppyman! You were dead on for your bottom three….only for some reason I can’t quite fathom, it was Lisa and not Kevin (chicken little)…..
🙂
I knew Kevin wouldn’t be going anywhere just yet….
Perfect bottom three tonight!
I was surprised to see Lisa instead of Kevin in the bottom 3, but not surprised about Melissa! 😉
Melissa was just asking to go. When I was singing, I did fall off the stage once, but I never forgot the lyrics. Twice!!